bit of a silly conversation this! for large parts of last season tom was best winger in the league! hes having a slow start and may well have been a bit at fault for couple of tries. But nearly all wingers have errors and defensive lapses in them,even the best of em. If like some suggest he's not interested cos he's gonna bugger off wouldnt he want to play well to up his value and put himself in demand! No player plays well 100% of the time! Hopefully find his best this weekend!

3 competitive games as a full side, what do people honestly expect?

The mind boggles it really does, new owner, new coaching and backroom staff and alot of new players, some peoples expectations are crazy it's going to take time, maybe even a season to get to the levels we want to be at. Friday was disappointing but I'm still confident we will come good.

the thing I find most disappointing is it's some of the same people that were still "giving Agar a chance" when all the world could see he was out of his depth, hypocrisy on the part of some.

It's the fact that most people said it would take time anyway and now after 1 loss, they are kicking off saying we will be scrapping for 8th etc, the term has been used alot but "Rome wasn't built in a day"

I'm still confident we will come good, most teams have an off day hopefully that was just a blip.

Wingers and centres do get the bumsrush in defence, its the hardest place to defend om the pitch and more often than not your wingers are the worst tacklers on the pitch but are usually exposed due to were the other players are. Same for defending against kicks

that why we should get the sliding defense right" we not do it"

After watching the trys, can't see how you can blame Tom for the first try as they took a risk kicked early and it paid off, all wingers defend in field early in the sets, then go out wide on the last tackle, if he had gone back early it would have left a huge gap.



The 2nd try he should have stuck with his man and trusted Yeaman to make the tackle.



If Tom does leave at the end of the season, it won't be the end of the world as it's not a massive pivotal position.



Hopefully we will have our eye on Broughton who we should have signed when he was on loan instead of keeping Todd Byrne.

In the nicest way possible you can fook right off!

Jodie & Danny Williams is the best wing combo I can remember in the 22 years I've been watching Salford. Pace to burn & Williams puts in some massive defensive hits. Besides, why would he leave a club on the up for one in terminal decline?!

Better than McAvoy and Rogers?

Yeah, definitely! McAvoy, IMO, should've done far more in his career than he actually did for someone with his size & pace. We've had a few decent wingers down the years (& more than our share of shockers

) but I reckon JB & DW (unless poached) will prove to be the best partnership for many a year.Nit always helps having a couple of half decent centres & if Moon & Gleeson can stay fit the wingers should score tries for fun. From what I've seen of us this season I genuinely believe, as an attacking force, our backline is top 6 material, we're just way too light in the forwards.

Good job you put the whistle in.Terminal decline....got more pass holders than your average home support,a chairman we now trust and a coach WHO turned you down and a director of rugby who you treated like $hit and knows far more than the total to$$er who is Simms.As for on the up...the only thing going up is your debts and the planes taking your Aussie coaches home after they realise what a balls up your club is