In his prime Briers had more tactical nous than Brough has, although he's never had Brough's physical attributes - pace especially.

Close call, but for sheer entertainment value I'd have Brough over Briers.

This.

I accept that its all about opinions and I also accept that I may be biased and that I've not seen enough of Brough, "but for sheer entertainment value" it's got to be Briers

No easy answer, both great players with different qualities. If Dr Koucash could do it he would have both lining up for salford next season thats for sure.

Briers has done some comical stuff over the years. Just last year when saints were rushing to make a scrum as they where trailing with a few mins to go and he joins saints side of the scrum ushering the saints players...cheeky bugger!

peterborough?

loughborough?



sorry couldn't resist

Middlesbrough?

Middlesborough?

right now...Myler

Brough had an off day today to be fair to him. Briers was better than him tonight and he was the water boy! Brough had a strop on and it spread around to others. Still, I'd have him as back up to Briers, Myler, Ratchford & O'Brien. So in short he will be 5th choice so in second thoughts, you can keep him

Borough of Furness



I'm lost?

Brough is good, but I'd never describe him as 'great.' Way too inconsistent. Barely remember doing anything last night. Briers was more effective as our Waterboy (B B B Booby Booshay).

brough not 100% fit, once again came off lastnight and wasnt doing much of the kicking duties..grix kicking off and lunt ..robinson getting more involved with the kicking... bit like at wakefield, funny we struggle their too! and the bradford game well dont go there