In this pressure environment already? Definitely throwing him in the deep end, although with his ability he probably will be capable.



If Grix is to be dropped, which I think is a little harsh as he wasn't the only one who under performed, Dave to come in. One more chopping salute on his home finale for the big fella!

Time for Big Dave to come in.

Why not? Some very young players have played in big matches. He looks more than capable of it. Grix is a nothing player, just a body, he doesn't really add anything.

If he was ready, we would have seen him at Widnes over Grix at least. He looks an extremely good player with bags of potential, but bringing him in now to line up opposite the likes of Manu for example, you're asking a hell of a lot from the kid when he'll also be defending alongside Briers & Ratch/Bridge in such a pressure game.



I think Dave is your next option if you must replace Grix. I think Smith will stick with more or less the same team though.

I can appreciate that hes a good player, however I can't say that I've ever seen him make a massive impact on the game











Well if we're getting rid of Grix for bombing two tries who are we bringing in for Atkins? He fluffed a couple and poor Riley was being made to look like a kn0bb for it.

If Riley had been behind Atkins instead of in front of him he would of had two walk-ins.

I'm just going off what i saw at the game. I also don't have the luxury of Sky so if Riley was in front then I apologize. But I've also read that Atkins was uncharacteristically throwing the ball away into tough. Think it was Sky Sports?

Not had the heart to watch the game back, doubt I ever will, but my thought at the game was that Riley appeared to be over-running Atkins hence the ball was finding touch behind Riley. The one time I remember Riley hanging back was the one time that Atkins put the ball in front of him and found touch again.



Just putting it down to 'one of those things'. On another day Atkins could have fed Riley with a hat-trick in the first half and we'd probably be sitting back on Saturday watching Saints battle it out against Hull.

If its true about Caravell then its game over.



We MIGHT beat Hull but we wont GET any further. Mark my WORDS.

Perhaps we should all just jump off a tall building and kill ourselves. After all, we are going to die at some point anyway.

We beat saints at LP without carvell several weeks ago , like i have said on another post we have just got to improve on a 54% completion rate , on paper we are a much better team than them , too much doom & gloom on ere at the moment

please go ahead.