Quote sally cinnamon="sally cinnamon"Didn't Morley, Monaghan and Carvell win three Challenge Cups, a heck of a lot more than Boyd, Tamati and Jackson.
They were also playing in a league where everyone was full time professional.
Back in Boyd, Tamati and Jackson's day it was largely a semi professional competition hence one team won everything, and it wasn't us.'"
Boyd, Tamati and Jackson also played in an era when front rowers played 80 minutes, and didn't go running off for a rest after half a dozen runs with the ball and a short spell of tackling....
Personally, if you are ranking those six, then Boyd is undoubtedly the best - A fantastic player, he could do most things bar kicking.... Run in with the ball, beat a man with a step, pass a slick short ball, throw a top class long ball out wide, tackle and, best of all, he could intimidate about as much as any RL player I've ever witnessed.
Morley was/is class, but, compared to Boyd, was/is a massive one-trick pony... Carvell is the same, just not as good as Morley.... Bob Jackson was the traditional workhorse prop - Pretty average compared to Boyd, but was an excellent foil to him. He was a quiet assassin, he never did a lot that would get a mention in the pub after the game, but I imagine he was one of those that opposition players fully respected and quietly dreaded coming up against.
As for the 2 hookers, its impossible to compare, because if one position as changed the most in the SL era, then its the number 9 one - Monaghan is head and shoulders over Tamati skill-wise, but if I got into a bit of trouble with an opposing player, or a side needed to put a bit of Wigan-style intimidation on an opposition, then I'd be more than happy knowing that Tamati was on my team.