Just watched the highlights video and this is my assessment of the tries we conceded.



1. Morley and Hauraki too slow to close down Ratchford. Hauraki could have done more to block the pass to Myler.



2. Warrington player didn't seem to play the ball properly with his foot, allowing a very fast PTB.



3. Debatable if Atkins was offside, level at best. Johnson should have stayed more upright because the bounce did him as he scooped down.



4. No complaints although Westward did run into Hansen but I don't think he would have got across anyway, great pass from Monaghan.

I thought myself on the restart on Saturday, I never understand why there isn't more urgency shown for this.



The team warning before the Walne binning escaped me, proves that fine young player as he is there is a definite need for his technique to improve.



Sorry but Westwoods tackle wasn't off the body/arm first, the more you look at it it was a cheap deliberate shot. I'd love to know what was being said between Myler and Chase in the aftermath as well.

It was Griffin to knocked in dead, the ball was quickly thrown to the 20m for the tap but Griffin was still picking himself up in the ingoal area.

Yeah, that's right. If Griffin had ran to the 20 and tapped himself then it would have been play on as it is you can't throw the ball to 20m for a quick tap unless the ref gives you the mark.

He made a mistake by listening to Chase pestering him for the ball.



Still struggling to see how Westwood's tackle can be deemed sending off sufficient (although I agree that -barely - the initial contact is with Walne's shoulder). If you can get called in for a cannonball tackle how do you rationalise Sin Bin sufficient for taking someone's head off?

A wild swinging Left Arm ( Patrick Ah Van on Charnley ) = Straight Red



A Wild Swinging Left arm ( Westwood on Walne ) Yellow Card - sin bin sufficient



conclusion, Walne isn't Charnley . Westwood isn't Ah Van.

Or that the referee in the Ah Van case got it wrong and both should have been a yellows?

Going off the reports, footage, and whatever else The RFL disciplinary panel look at, Westwood escaped the ban because the initial contact was fine. This drastically reduces the offence. I thought it was a red too, but I was 50 metres away, saw the incident at full speed once and had a few pints down me.

In my experience that's when things are at their most clear

Reality is a chronic condition brought on by lack of alcohol



And I see that this is my 1000 th post,so time for a drink. It's 5 o'clock somewhere!

Only 1000 - seems like more!