One win against a very poor Hull side hardly cements Agar's place as a top coach.

Let them enjoy the odd win. For the sake of Wakey and RL, I hope Agar doesn't make watching RL seem like the massive chore it did while he was at Hull.

I thought the predictable anti Agar drivel from Hull fans was funny, but this is gold medal.



So Mal Reilly who crowned an illustrious coaching career with an NRL GF win has no man management skills! UNREAL



I suggest in many cases on this thread but especially on this one fans look at the senile BOD and the often gutless and talentless bunch of players these men had to deal with - most of whom were not fit to lace Malcom's boots - and as a Wakey fan that's hard to say.

Correct, and not finishing bottom and/or getting you relegated hardly makes him the worst does it.



The job at Hull was to big for him, but he's not the first and judging by yesterday won't be the last.

Steve Mcnamara for turning the Bulls from heroes to zeros in the blink of an eye!

He certainly turned a top team into a mediocre team, whereas lots of the others made mediocre or poor team worse.

I think a lot of Reilly's problem was that he himself was so ultra competitive (frighteningly but funnily so if you read Matt Johns' book on him), and I think just really struggled with average players.

After reading through all of these posts I'm ready to give my impartial view and choose a worthy winner.



Any coach that can take a team from 4th to bottom within 2 seasons has to be the worst SL coach ever



Take a bow Kevin Walters.

My shout is....



John Joyner



Still a legend as a player though.

Peter Walsh for Hull FC (or Sharks at the time) was pretty poor, although he didn't have a squad to compete really. He was head coach for our first season in 1998 and half of 99



Played - 32

Won - 8

Lost 24



Points Scored - 529

Conceded - 813



He lost the first 9 games of the 99 season which cost him his job. There was no dramatic improvement and we finished 2nd bottom. But the thing that sticks in FC fans throats with Walsh is Hull replaced Phil Sigsworth who clearly wanted to have a crack at Super League having taken us up but was overlooked for a suposedly better coach. Would rather have given Siggy a crack.

Ian Millward @ Wigan we even stopped going for a while.

Lock the thread now,the winner is darren abram at leigh end of story total