Maybe early, but still not the news anyone would have wanted to hear!

I found myself hoping this was the famously terrible Aussie media jumping the gun and reporting on something that hasn't been confirmed - but still an awful situation either way.



Best wishes to the lad.

Dreadful news and lets hope that JB's take on it turns out to be the correct one. If ever there was proof that people who carry out these tackles should be banned for a long, long time then this is it.

I would hope this is jumping the gun as medical records are private.



It's something that I've never known for many years. I seem to recall maybe 10 - 15 years ago a player in the UK having a horrendous injury.



I'm sure we all hope he can walk again.

At least he his now bereaving on his own & out of the induced coma what is a positive thing...... lets hope he makes a good recovery, & i feel for the fella & his family & team mates.

Quote bewareshadows="bewareshadows"I would hope this is jumping the gun as medical records are private. It's something that I've never known for many years. I seem to recall maybe 10 - 15 years ago a player in the UK having a horrendous injury. I'm sure we all hope he can walk again.'" Might be John Power your thinking of? There was an article written on him a couple of years ago. www.dailymail.co.uk/health/artic ... ghter.html

Quote bewareshadows="bewareshadows"I would hope this is jumping the gun as medical records are private. It's something that I've never known for many years. I seem to recall maybe 10 - 15 years ago a player in the UK having a horrendous injury. I'm sure we all hope he can walk again.'" Might be John Power your thinking of? There was an article written on him a couple of years ago. www.dailymail.co.uk/health/artic ... ghter.html

Quote Errlee Berd="Errlee Berd"Might be John Power your thinking of? There was an article written on him a couple of years ago. www.dailymail.co.uk/health/artic ... ghter.html'" There was also Pete Stephenson who broke his neck playing for East Hull about 10 years ago. He was told that he would never walk again but has made great progress over the years. Does a lot of good work for the RL benevolent fund too.

Quote Errlee Berd="Errlee Berd"Might be John Power your thinking of? There was an article written on him a couple of years ago. www.dailymail.co.uk/health/artic ... ghter.html'" There was also Pete Stephenson who broke his neck playing for East Hull about 10 years ago. He was told that he would never walk again but has made great progress over the years. Does a lot of good work for the RL benevolent fund too.

I agree that we don't punish tackles that put players at risk like this enough. However this is one of those instances where no foul was committed, it was a freak accident that just shows what a dangerous game this is and anyone who puts their body on the line has my respect. In this instance, whilst McKinnon is the real victim, I can really sympathise with the guys who made the tackle. It must be awful having to carry something like this on your shoulders.

Have to disagree but this is not the time for it. The tackling players lifted his hips higher than his shoulders that is a foul and although we see it many times per game and have almost become used to it. it is dangerous and should be heavily penalised.

It's just awful news - literally sends a chill over me whenever I think of it - the panic on his face will stay with me a long time.



As for the tackle, although I believe there was no intent at all to injure, or commit foul play, once you lift the legs (he gripped inside his leg - which is illegal anyway) you have a responsibility to ensure the player doesn't go above horizontal and lands safely. In this case, McLean couldn't control it due to the weight of the other players, and McKinnon's momentum and technique - but ultimately, he shouldn't lift the legs in that case if he can't control it.



I don't blame McLean, it's the tactics used across all of RL now, but this one has gone badly wrong.

It's heart breaking to feel that someone playing sport can almost meet their end in this way.



Not sure what could be done about it to minimize the danger. There are malicious and dangerous tackles but in the end freak tackles also happen.



In the Leeds Saints game on Friday. Roby got right under a player in the tackle. No reaching between the legs, just a strong drive, that player could have tipped over, if it was not for Walker latching onto the top of the tackle. In the end it was controlled well, but these things can go easily wrong with tacklers pulling in all directions and attackers wriggling to get their arms free and release the ball for 2nd phase.



In American football they are all padded up with neck pads too, but I'm not sure it reduces the danger.

Yeah agree with this, that must be one of the most terrifying things to happen to anybody, let alone a pro athlete.



As others have said, we all know what can happen when things go wrong - terrible to see it though.



I hope they take similar action they took with the heart monitors and get this sorted out, feel terrible for the lad and would hate to see it happen top anyone else.