Quote Bullseye="Bullseye"I'm not sure I agree with you on Kearney. At the moment I'd say he's having his best ever year with us and has scored and made a lot of tries. While Gale was out he ran his blood to water trying to organise and be on the end of things. Without being on the field it's hard to tell how much leadership he provides but he's one of our most influential senior players if tries and assists are anything to go by.
On the downside his positional play isn't top class and he's not exactly Mumby-esque in defence (who is?). But to me these are fairly minor quibbles.
If we did allow him to leave who would take his place? I like the look of Naughton but he's a way off SL yet I think. I certainly wouldn't be putting Platt there. Kear is sound under the kick and is quite quick but lacks the ability to chime into the line and make play for others from what I've seen.
On the hooker debate I thought Diskin was excellent at Leeds so I'd be reluctant to write him off yet.'"
I am in no doubt that Kearney is having his best year by far with us, but I think my issue is that when he makes mistakes (which is quite often if you look at the stats) he tends to make very costly errors, which ends up costing us points. (See Leeds and Wigan for instance)
I appreciate his willingness to run his blood to water and ability to get on the end of a pass to score, but so does Danny McGuire but I wouldn't have him in my team.
Maybe i've been spoiled by the quality of the fullbacks we've had over the years (Keith Mumby, Sprogger Spruce, Michael Withers, Nathan Graham etc) that I don't give him enough merit. Had we the ability to splash a bit of cash around, I'd say he was worth keeping, but ateotd we don't so i'm probably taking a little bit of an over-progmatic approach when than thinking about him and his worth to the team.
With regards to Disko, write him off at your peril. Whilst his body might be struggling a little, his mind looks as sharp as ever. My own personal opinion is that we have the best of both in Disko and Heath and would want to see them both in RAB next year at least, with O Brien completing his apprenticeship with a view to stepping in to the void in 2015.
Lulia is a funny one. I cannot personally remember him putting Foster in too many times and the defence seems to have the measure of him and his hand-off following last seasons exploits. Maybe the Leeds offer doesn't look too bad now. That said, I'd rather have him in our shirt than a Rhinos one.
Blythe when fit has been solid and i'd like to try and get him perminently (if possible), Foster well worth another year or two as is Sidlow. Langley offers a reminder back to the days of glory and for me it would be sad to lose that last remaining link.
Purtell is the one that doesnt sit well with me. Part of me says that the guy has done really well coming back from what he did and that he needs time to settle back in. Another side says that he wasn't exactly setting the world alight before magic weekend and that he was probably a good Mr Reliable in a team that desperately needed some stability. My heart says keep him, my head says cut him lose
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cfb2/8cfb200db08b7d1ae033686837d29848fb8c8859" alt="Sad icon_sad.gif"