Totalloiner said Kirke wasnt good enough about a year ago. I argued he was. He was probably right tbh.

A year ago he was good enough, it's his form this year that has slumped alarmingly but he's not on his own in that regard.

Was he good enough because those around him were carrying him or was he really good enough?



I thought he was good enough but perhaps I was wrong. Unbelievable I know but it sometimes does happen

i think a bit of both the fringe players tend to play well and in some cases above their natural talent when you have quality performers playing at their peak around them.

I still think he will come good but when everyones fit i don't see him as 1st choice 17.

did kirke ever have a long enough run to look bad without breaking his leg and coming back for the playoffs?

Thought Kirke has made short, but significant, contributions to the last two GF's and been a solid squad player in the past. He's clearly not a starting back rower and looks to be off the pace this year. There are some guys that can lift their game in a champion team but drop a level when a team is playing poorly and not really offer much of a lift. When the team's playing well he seems to fit okay, and as we've seen this year when the team's struggling he struggles more than most.



Let's see what he looks like if we hit some form.

That was always my view.

He's jonny average who has been riding the coat tails of a great team.



The job he does, can be done by a kid. Jesus H, I reckon I could do 4 hit ups in a game.

Is he in the academy?

I think he is, although he's always got his Dad's carpentry firm to fall back on if it doesn't work out.

You're thinking of his step Dad. His real Father makes Damo look like a workaholic. He did 6 days graft ages ago and that's been it since. Lazy sod.

I always think of Kirke as a useful fringe player. I wouldn't play him every week but I think he's useful for rotation without risking a young lad.

Obviously he's out of form at the moment but I think that could be said of many players, and I'd agree that when the team steps up he seems to as well.